Wheeltapper Pub - Manhattan
Today we had lunch at the Wheeltapper Pub in the Fitzpatrick Hotel on 44th Street in Manhattan between Lexington and 3rd Avenue.
The pub has a friendly staff of mostly Irish wait staff. The decor is nice and the selection of beer on tap is good for an Irish pub. The restaurant is based on a railroad theme with gauges, dials and faux tracks on the floor. My favorite beers on tap include Bass, Guinness, Smithwicks.
The lunch menu is relatively light, as far as choices go.
Today I had the Irish stew which was good but not for $16.00. The portion size was about 16 fluid ounces. The broth was tasty but the gaminess of the lamb was well evident in the broth. The large pieces of potato and carrot were barely cooked through. The stew was supposed to contain barley and it did... about 10 pieces in the whole bowl. The first bite of lamb was tough. It could have cooked through another half an hour or so. Other pieces of lamb ranged from tough to perfectly cooked. It seemed like they combined two batches of soup, one with undercooked lamb and the other with perfectly cooked lamb.
The wife had corned beef and cabbage for $13. The corned beef was practically tasteless. If you concentrated enough on the meat you could detect the corned beef taste. The cabbage seemed to be cooked in plain water with no salt or flavoring. Overall a pretty tasteless dish.
On previous occasions we've had the Irish breakfast which was very good and the fish & chips which were good.
The pub also deemed fit to charge a 15% gratuity on the check. I usually tip more than that, but if they only want 15%, that is fine with me. (I know that I could add an additional tip, but when a place with poor food adds a tip for a party of two to the bill, I get a bit put off.)
I suggest that if you are in the Grand Central area of Manhattan and you want an Irish pub, you will find a lot of choices so look beyond the Wheeltapper.
The pub has a friendly staff of mostly Irish wait staff. The decor is nice and the selection of beer on tap is good for an Irish pub. The restaurant is based on a railroad theme with gauges, dials and faux tracks on the floor. My favorite beers on tap include Bass, Guinness, Smithwicks.
The lunch menu is relatively light, as far as choices go.
Today I had the Irish stew which was good but not for $16.00. The portion size was about 16 fluid ounces. The broth was tasty but the gaminess of the lamb was well evident in the broth. The large pieces of potato and carrot were barely cooked through. The stew was supposed to contain barley and it did... about 10 pieces in the whole bowl. The first bite of lamb was tough. It could have cooked through another half an hour or so. Other pieces of lamb ranged from tough to perfectly cooked. It seemed like they combined two batches of soup, one with undercooked lamb and the other with perfectly cooked lamb.
The wife had corned beef and cabbage for $13. The corned beef was practically tasteless. If you concentrated enough on the meat you could detect the corned beef taste. The cabbage seemed to be cooked in plain water with no salt or flavoring. Overall a pretty tasteless dish.
On previous occasions we've had the Irish breakfast which was very good and the fish & chips which were good.
The pub also deemed fit to charge a 15% gratuity on the check. I usually tip more than that, but if they only want 15%, that is fine with me. (I know that I could add an additional tip, but when a place with poor food adds a tip for a party of two to the bill, I get a bit put off.)
I suggest that if you are in the Grand Central area of Manhattan and you want an Irish pub, you will find a lot of choices so look beyond the Wheeltapper.
